Creative Writing Critique Guidelines

Creative Writing Critique Guidelines-28
“As for literary criticism in general: I have long felt that any reviewer who expresses rage and loathing for a novel or a play or a poem is preposterous.He or she is like a person who has put on full armor and attacked a hot fudge sundae or a banana split.” Few things will more quickly deflate a writer than unnecessarily harsh criticism.Being constructive means coming to the critique with the ultimate goal of helping the writer improve.

In order for people to listen, they must feel that the person criticizing them has their best interest in mind, and being harsh doesn’t communicate your best interest.

In my earliest days writing, I received some negative criticism from a writer who decided to berate me for penning a bad phrase rather than explaining to me why the phrase didn’t work.

Critics must contend with the reality that writing is art, people have opinions about art, and those opinions are not always going to be eruptions of praise.

There is no safer environment to honestly and succinctly point out problem areas in a piece of writing than a forum designed for that very purpose.

This section is not so much about “It is important to appreciate the amount of subjectivity and pre-understanding all readers and listeners bring to the process of interpreting acts of human communication.

But unless a speaker or author can retain the right to correct someone’s interpretation by saying ‘but that’s not what I meant’ or ‘that’s not even consistent with what I meant,’ all human communication will quickly break down.”—what the author desired the audience to receive from their work.The problem was not the content of his criticism, but its malicious delivery.Had he come to my work with the desire to be genuinely helpful, I would have listened to what he had to say, and I might even have gained some enlightenment during a formative time in my writing career.Because he was rude, I insulated myself to his criticism.Years later, I reviewed the work and realized his criticism was valid.Conversely, we might be willing to share our opinions with other writers while struggling with our competence. If we’re critiquing on Scribophile, we may feel that we are wasting one of the author’s coveted “spotlight” critiques.Having used Scribophile on-and-off since 2009, I’ve seen countless readers qualify their commentary on my own work (“I don’t read your genre,” “I haven’t read your previous chapters,” “I’m not good with grammar,” etc.) and I’ve seen even more cry woe on the forums about how they can’t critique because they’re not experienced enough, not educated enough, or not talented enough.As you interact with works on Scribophile or elsewhere, remember to always approach the task of criticism with a desire to be genuinely helpful.If your criticism is built on this foundation, your commentary will be constructive regardless of your competence and experience.Being honest and being brutal are not the same thing.Critics must learn to express hard truths without coddling and without being jerks.


Comments Creative Writing Critique Guidelines

  • A Critique Template for Authors and Writer's Groups BookLife

    Perchance to Dream Tapping Your Infinite Creativity →. A Critique Template for Authors and Writer's Groups. Example “Search your document for 'that', 'quickly' and the phrase, 'working up the courage' – you use these a.…

  • How to be a good writing workshop participant - The Writer

    Here are 18 rules for being a good writing workshop participant. Being in a workshop also means that you have to help other writers with their creative process, which may sound. Here are some guidelines for being the best presenter, reader and. Make sure that your submission is ready for critique.…

  • Critique Guidelines - The Writers' Loft

    Learn to be an excellent critique partner by using these guidelines. At the Writers' Loft, we take community very seriously. Please try to give feedback in a way.…

  • Writing a critique - QUT citewrite

    Guide to writing a critique. intended audience, development of argument, structure of evidence or creative style. The following template, which showcases the main features of a critique, is provided as one example.…

  • Keys to Giving Constructive Writing Critiques - Write It Sideways

    The purpose of critiquing someone's writing is to point out the flaws in order to show them where they can improve. But it's also about.…

  • Critique guidelines and ideas - Jessica Abel

    Keep it civil The work posted here is fair game for critique, and while true that. Don't take an author's interest in exploring difficult material in writing as an.…

  • How to Give Constructive Writing Feedback Grammarly

    The goal of a critique isn't to show how much you know, it's to help the. How to Give Writing Feedback that's Constructive, Not Crushing. We're fragile people, we creative types. And. Choose a few of the most important things the writer can do to improve the manuscript, then point out an example to help.…

  • Nonfiction Critique Guidelines Arlington Heights Memorial Library

    Nonfiction Critique Guidelines. What is the main idea the writer is trying to get across? Is the writer trying to be humorous, serious, straightforward, etc? Does this.…

  • Ways to Make the Most of a Critique Group Writer's Digest

    Today's guest post is from writer Susan Cushman, a monthly regular here at. Read her personal blog, learn about the 2011 Memphis Creative.…

  • How to Write a Great Critique - Writing Academy Scribophile

    You're at Scribophile, a writing community for serious writers. If we're critiquing on Scribophile, we may feel that we are wasting one of the author's. Plenty of writers and editors don't hold English or Creative Writing degrees, and while I. Herein are general guidelines and considerations that I've found helpful over the.…

The Latest from ©